Earlier Intervention Makes a Difference in Literacy Skills for Children with Deafness

Research By Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH, Susan Wiley, MD

Post Date: June 24, 2021 | Publish Date: June 2, 2021

→

New clinical trial results further support early-as-possible intervention to support literacy skill development among children with hearing loss.

Children who are deaf or hard of hearing fare better in preschool literacy skills when early intervention begins before six months of age, according to the latest findings from a research team at Cincinnati Children’s.

Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPHSusan Wiley, MD, and colleagues have been exploring the benefits of technology-assisted language intervention (TALI) for the past several years.

Now, in the June issue of the Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, the team reports that early intervention works best when the work begins very early.

The team compared the timing of support among 256 children enrolled in early intervention programs through the Ohio Department of Education.

They found that children enrolled in EI before age 6 months had consistently higher scores in emergent literacy components, such as picture naming, rhyming and alliteration, versus children enrolled after age 6 months.

Read more below about the TALI approach.

When preschoolers and elementary students with deafness or hearing loss fall behind on language development, an intervention using a tablet with special software does a better job than traditional therapies at helping them catch up, according to new research published Jan. 15, 2021, in Pediatrics.

Language development can be a major challenge when young children lack hearing. Up to 40% of children under 6 with deafness develop language gaps that make it harder for them to function socially and succeed academically.

A clinical trial to explore the benefits of technology-assisted language intervention (TALI), was led by Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH, Susan Wiley, MD, and colleagues at Cincinnati Children’s. The study involved 41 children randomly assigned to standard care or the TALI approach. After 24 weeks, the children in the TALI group demonstrated significantly greater increases in the length of phrases used to express themselves, along with improvements in the number of different words spoken and in conversational turn-taking.

The research team credits the improvements to participants’ access to a mix of images, written words, and consistent feedback through a software program that was integrated into therapy sessions and used at home.

A Tool for Language Development

A Tool for Language Development

This screenshot depicts the tablet interface used by participants in the TALI clinical trial. Source: Cincinnati Children’s

“With spoken language, messages are said or spoken out loud and then disappear. Children who are hard of hearing sometimes struggle to catch and process all of what is said. As a result, they may have difficulty developing language skills in the same way as their hearing peers,” Meinzen-Derr says.  “This device allows a child to look at the words, message or phrase as many times as needed, and work with the words in a way that is different than listening.”

While the intervention involves off-the-shelf software, success with the intervention requires a speech-language pathologist (SLP). The research team does not recommend that parents pursue do-it-yourself versions of TALI.

“The SLP will set up the technology at the right language level for the child and will offer guidance of how to build on a child’s current language skill level.  The SLP also coaches parents on how to use this approach in everyday life,” Meinzen-Derr says.

Next steps include using a $3 million grant from the National Institutes of Health to expand the clinical testing to a second location in Colorado.

“We expected to see improvement but we were thrilled to see that it worked as well as it did,” Meinzen-Derr says. “What this shows is that we can intervene early when traditional care does not result in strong progress. There are alternatives to consider.”

Learn about a family’s experience with TALI

Learn more about the value of early intervention

Publication Information

Original Title:Association of Age of Enrollment in Early Intervention with Emergent Literacy in Children Who Are Deaf or Hard of Hearing
Published in:Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics
Publish date:June 2, 2021

Read the study

Research By

  • Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH

    Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH

    Director, Biostatistics, Epidemiology, & Research Design Program

    My research focuses on understanding and optimizing developmental outcomes of children who are deaf/hard of hearing so that all children can reach their full potential.

  • Susan Wiley, MD

    Susan Wiley, MD

    Director, Division of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics

    As a developmental pediatrician, I specialize in treating children with developmental disabilities, particularly Down syndrome and Rubinstein Taybi-Syndrome. I also treat children who are deaf or hard of hearing along with developmental disabilities (Deaf/Hard of Hearing Plus).